Yield Curve Hysteria

By Sonal Desai | More Articles by Sonal Desai

The inversion of the Treasury yield curve has recently gotten a lot of attention in the financial press as being a harbinger of economic malaise ahead. Franklin Templeton Fixed Income CIO Sonal Desai says these conclusions are misguided.

The recent inversion of the US Treasury yield curve has had the financial press in a bit of a frenzy.

I see a glaring contradiction in the fact that so many market participants and commentators emphasise the heightened level of economic uncertainty, and at the same time seem to consider flat or inverted yield curves as foolproof predictors of a recession. I see this as completely misguided — I think the yield curve is telling us nothing about what lies ahead for the real economy.

Yes, protracted uncertainty on trade is having some impact on business sentiment. But we have lived with trade uncertainty for almost three years now, with very little economic impact. The US economy is holding up well, and now it benefits from a more dovish US Federal Reserve (Fed).

China has shown a bit of weakness, but not a sharp slowdown; and the latest data show that China’s lower exports to the United States have been offset by stronger exports to the rest of the world. The weakness in Europe is more pronounced, notably in Germany as we’ve seen with recent gross domestic product data, but by no means a collapse.

The US economy continues to create jobs at a robust clip, even with the unemployment rate already at a 50-year low. Employees’ wages and salaries grew at 4.7% in 2017, 5% in 2018 and 5.1% in the first half of this year.1 Household consumption powers the economy, and the household saving rate as of June this year is at a very healthy 8.1%.2

In short: the economic data show no evidence that either the United States or the global economy is approaching a recession.

Government bond markets are still distorted by the major role that central banks continue to play. And now the Fed has cut interest rates and signalled the possibility of further reductions; the European Central Bank has opened the door to a resumption of quantitative easing. Major central banks are essentially inviting investors to ignore the economic data and bet on lower yields.

So, I think fixed income markets are betting on the Fed, and the Fed has just taken a dovish turn—ignoring the economic data. But this betting on the Fed gives no indication whatsoever on where the economy is going. In other words, I think the Treasury yield curve has no value whatsoever as a predictor of recession. It’s just a good predictor of Fed dovishness, for now, and a sign of some panic in the markets.

The markets and the Fed seem to be looking at each other, feeding each other’s fears, and completely ignoring what’s actually going on in the real economy.

1. Source: US Bureau of Economic Analysis.
2. Source: Ibid.

 

Sonal Desai

About Sonal Desai

Sonal Desai, Ph.D. is Executive Vice President and Chief Investment Officer of the Franklin Templeton Fixed Income Group. In this role, Dr. Desai oversees Franklin's Municipal, Corporate Credit, Floating Rate Securitized, Multisector, Global (including Emerging Markets), Money Market, and Local Asset Management Fixed Income teams, and co-chairs the Group's Fixed Income Policy Committee. She is a member of Franklin Resources' Executive Committee, a small group of the company's top leaders responsible for shaping the firm's overall strategy. In addition, she serves on the firm's Management and Investment Committees.

View more articles by Sonal Desai →