LOGIN JOIN SHARECAFE SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER ADVERTISE
share cafe logo  
 
SHARECAFE COMMENTARY

Are You Dangerously Hooked On Dividends?
BY KENT KWAN - 12/02/2016 | VIEW MORE ARTICLES BY ATLASTREND

We recently started writing a series of articles to provide a practical look at how our investment management team deal with real investment situations. For part 2 of this series, we look at the ever popular question about dividends.

Our investment team have all spent a number of years working overseas before returning to Australia. What we all found coming home has been the tremendous interest in dividends among listed share investors and their advisers. We would go so far as saying some investors may even show signs of addiction to dividends.

Like all addictions, we certainly don’t think this is healthy. In fact, when we invest we actively avoid what we sometimes internally call the “Pocket Money Syndrome”

“Pocket Money Syndrome”

We’ve all been there. Cash is transferred to your bank account on a regular basis in the form of dividends from your share investments.

Does it feel rewarding to have passive income?

Yes, but unfortunately some investors may also start focusing more on the regular dividend income rather than how the shares generating those dividends are performing. Similar to a teenager worrying about how much pocket money they are getting rather than their parents’ real financial situation. This “pocket money syndrome” can lead investors into dangerous investment situations.

Focus On Cash Generation Not Dividends

When we assess an investment, the ability of that company to generate cash is a key performance measure. In contrast, a company’s potential dividend yield and management’s official statements on future dividends are factors we attach less value to. Let’s look at BHP Billiton which is a topical example:

- For financial year 2015 BHP had free cash flow (after paying for operating expenses, capital expenditure costs, interest and tax) of US$6 billion. The company paid out approximately all of this free cash flow in dividends to shareholders. At the time of its annual general meeting in August 2015, BHP committed to its “progressive dividend” policy. We thought that was a brave move given falling commodity prices were already negatively impacting cash generation. This should have raised some alarm bells for BHP shareholders.

- Fast forward to today, the cash flow situation has deteriorated further with the sustained falls in commodity prices. From our calculations, BHP may end up with free cash flow (including reductions in capital expenditure) of up to US$4 billion less than the previous financial year. To pay out US$6 billion in dividends again for financial year 2016 would effectively mean the company is borrowing money to pay its dividends. That is not a sustainable strategy even for a company like BHP against the backdrop of severe commodity price weakness. We believe a prudent board of directors will need to substantially reduce BHP’s dividends.

The decline in BHP’s free cash flow should have been and should still be a major concern for shareholders. Any impending dividend cut will hurt but more importantly the lower cash flow generation will also reduce BHP’s ability to pursue longer term growth. Unless commodity prices increase significantly in the next few years, BHP shareholders might well be invested in a company that will just be defending its market position (e.g. cutting costs, reducing capital expenditure, protecting its balance sheet and repeat). Not awful but certainly not where you might want to invest your money for the next few years.

Focusing on BHP’s current and future cash generation would have revealed the above issues perhaps 12 to 18 months ago. In contrast, waiting for the official change in dividends is usually too late. From experience we know board directors of large companies are notorious for not wanting to change stated dividend policies in order to cater to investors with a pocket money syndrome. When their hand is finally forced, it is usually after the share price has dropped significantly. This way the board can say a reduced dividend still provides a reasonable dividend yield for investors.

In the meantime, shareholders have suffered a major decline in the capital value of their shares (in BHP’s case approximately -50% in the last 12 months) all to hang on and hope for a 5% to 6% dividend yield. Therein lies the danger of investing in shares driven primarily by a thirst for dividends without carefully considering the parent company’s broader cash flow situation.

Many parents teach their kids about not being overly reliant on pocket money as they grow up. We could all do worse than apply the same lessons when investing in shares.

AtlasTrend has just launched a 4 part series on the listed stocks you should get exposure to in 2016. Register to become a member at www.atlastrend.com/register (it takes less than 1 minute) to start receiving the AtlasTrend series of Trending Insights exclusive to our members.



View More Articles By AtlasTrend

Kent Kwan is a co-founder of AtlasTrend, a global equities fund manager that makes it easy for anyone to invest in the world's most thriving trends.


Disclaimer: Atlastrend Pty Ltd (ABN 83 605 565 491) is a Corporate Authorised Representative (No. 001233660) of Fundhost Limited (ABN 69 092 517 087, AFS License No. 233045). Any advice contained in this communication is general advice only. None of the information provided is, or should be considered to be, personal financial advice. The content has been prepared without taking into account your personal objectives, financial situations or needs. If you consider it necessary you should seek your own advice before making any financial or investment decisions. The information provided in this communication is believed to be accurate at the time of writing. None of Atlastrend Pty Ltd, Fundhost Limited or their related entities nor their respective officers and agents accept responsibility for any inaccuracy in, or any actions taken in reliance upon, that information.

Any managed investment fund product (Fund) mentioned in this communication is offered at www.atlastrend.com via a Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) which will contain all the details of the offer. The PDS is issued by Fundhost Limited as responsible entity for the investment fund products. Before making any decision to make or hold any investment in a Fund you should consider the PDS in full. The PDS is available at www.atlastrend.com or by calling AtlasTrend on 1800 589 778. Investment returns are not guaranteed. Past performance is not an indicator of future performance.



 

RECENTLY ADDED TO SHARECAFE


 › Marcus Today End Of Day Report
 › Tuesday At The Close
 › Brokers Keen On Cleanaway-Tox
 › Cleaner Focus For Gale Pacific
 › Review Of 2017, Outlook For 2018 - Still In The 'Sweet Spot', But Expect More Volatility Ahead
 › Market At Midday On Tuesday
 › Six Reasons To Be Wary Right Now
 › Why A Rise In Rates Won't Mean Much
 › The Quest For Trading Truth
 › How Skyscrapers Predict Market Crashes?
 › Overnight: Crypto Crazy
 › MIN - Morgan Stanley rates the stock as Overweight
 › RAN - Morgans rates the stock as Hold
 › AGL - UBS rates the stock as Buy
More ShareCafe   

GET THE SHARECAFE BREAKFAST BRIEFING


Delivered free to your inbox before the market opens each trading day. Sign up below +

SHARECAFE VIDEO


View More Videos